Right, we have gone through the various types of protection assurance available and covered most of the standard pitfalls above, so how does this relate to your circumstances?
Everyone’s circumstances are different and all I can illustrate here are general principals, not hard and fast rules, nor offer individual advice, so don’t read into this more than there is. Ultimately, getting proper independent professional advice based on your own individual circumstances is by far the best option:-

Scenario 1: Single man, late 20s, no personal debt, in good health, parents divorced and estranged, with a budget of £150 per month.
Solution: As this client has no debt and no dependents, all protection needs to be geared around his needs, especially as the Bank of Mum and Dad is probably not available. Income protection is paramount, with life cover and critical illness as a secondary issue to cover a potential future mortgage at today’s rates or to provide a lump sum if he gets seriously ill, but it does not kill him.
Reasoning: The client has no family to fall back on in adversity and will need to make provision for his own care if his health fails. Buying life cover when healthy is a good idea if there is a need in the near future; a mortgage for a new house and critical illness cover would be sufficient justification, (life and critical illness is often cheaper than critical illness on its own and remember, most life and critical illness quotes are on an “accelerated basis”, only one payout, whichever is the sooner).
Scenario 2: For a couple in their early 20s, in good health with one young child, a large mortgage, credit card debts for furniture, both parents working and a budget of about £100 per month.
Solution: First priority is the clearance of all capital debt, then the replacement of lost income, then income protection for sickness. The available budget is the key issue here, so there will need to be some juggling between products, but in outline, a small level term assurance in joint names to clear any capital debt, then a Family Income Plan in joint names for the lost income, probably written to retirement age and two income protection plans to cover to retirement age.
Reasoning: If the worst comes to the worst, benefits will provide a basic living if you are unable to work, but do not provide a lifeline for mortgage or other debts, so clearing that is paramount. Replacement of income is the next priority after a death, as benefits are not generous if the partner/spouse has died. A family income benefit is the cheapest form of life cover and will meet that need. If there is any budget remaining, then income protection for sickness is the next need. Critical illness will be too expensive for this scenario and income protection is likely to cover most of the risk in any case.
Scenario 3: A married couple in their 30s, both working, he is a civil servant, she is a part time administrator, 2 young children, a new 25 year interest only mortgage and already have a mortgage protection plan, (MPPI), for 25 years. Budget is very tight, as they have just bought a new, larger house, so no more than £100 per month.
Solution: First priority is the clearance of the mortgage, which the MPPI may do, so the details must be checked to ensure that cover is not duplicated. If the MPPI only covers sickness income, then a life plan in joint names will need to be added to clear the full mortgage; in any event the value of the MPPI plan should be assessed, as some are poor value and should be cancelled and replaced if necessary. Next priority is income replacement on death, so a Family Income plan in joint names to their retirement age(s). As a civil servant, he will have significant death in service benefits, so the income cover may be reduced. After about 5 years service, he will also be entitled to 6 months full pay and six months half pay in the event of sickness, so an income protection plan could be deferred significantly, reducing premium. If the budget allows, she should be provided with an income protection plan on a suitable deferred period, but the couple may choose not to cover her sickness. Medical insurance through Benenden Trust is available to public sector employees at very reduced rates, so they should look to that as a part of their financial planning.
Reasoning: Although they have already some cover in place, the adviser must check that it is appropriate and economic. The existing MPPI may cover all of the necessary bases, but it is generally only available to cover the mortgage payment, not general living expenses and may or may not cover life claims. Benefits available as part of employment should be assessed as part of the financial planning process and gaps filled rather than cover duplicated. Other than the above, the issues are similar to Scenario 2 above.
Scenario 4: A couple in their 50s, with two children over 16, but not yet fully independent, he runs a business that generates a good income and contributes to a pension, she is a housewife, they have a repayment mortgage with 10 years to go. The total household assets are in excess of £1.5Million and the husband has recently been diagnosed with heart and cholesterol issues. There is some life cover in place, a level term assurance in his name with 10 years to go, worth £100,000, slightly more than the mortgage.
Solution: The first priority is to make the best use of the existing plan. If the plan is not already written in trust for the remaining family, it needs to be, which should be an administration procedure. The next priority is income replacement for the wife and children, so the terms of his pension need to be examined and cover tailored to match any remaining gaps. The wife can be provided with income protection on a “homemakers” basis to cover her potential illness. The potential Inheritance Tax, (IHT), issue in the event of a early death for both parents needs to be addressed, especially as the second death will be the trigger event.
Reasoning: Protection after any diagnosis of serious illness will be very expensive, if you can find anyone to offer cover at all. The family assets suggest that there may be a potential Inheritance Tax issue, so adding a further £100,000 to his estate on death would be a major error, an additional £40,000, (40%) in tax would be payable. If the policy was written in trust, the proceeds would fall outside of his estate and would be available to his dependents immediately, without having to wait for probate. For many insurance providers, trusts are available “off the shelf”, so assigning the plan will be a simple administration procedure. In the event of his death, his pension assets would normally be available to his spouse, so that may offset any income requirements, but she can be insured in her own right at ordinary rates. The IHT issue can be addressed with a second death life plan in the short run and IHT planning over the next 7 years. (The Financial Services Authority do not regulate Inheritance Tax Planning).
Reasons to be cautious
If the person trying to sell you protection insurance cannot give you a clear explanation of why you need it and how much, then DON’T BUY IT! I won’t argue with the normal bank proposition that life cover is a good idea, but I will dispute how much and where from. Doing a protection review in a systematic manner, putting the needs of the client paramount will usually come to a different answer than just enough to clear the loan! If you have made the decisions, remember that a comparison website cannot give you the various factors that should influence your product, option and sum assured choices, it’s just a robot to give you rates. You cannot sue it if you get your cover wrong and you cannot discuss your ideas and ambitions with it either.
Discussing your individual circumstance with a qualified IFA will ensure, (by statute), that you receive the best possible advice that recognises your personal circumstances, needs and minimises the potential for inappropriate cover.
Contact me with queries
If anyone is looking for general advice, then please write in to the blog and I would be happy to help with anonymous advice posted here. Alternatively, please call us on 0116 253 5600 and ask to speak to an IFA, (Independent Financial Adviser), for a no-obligation discussion.
If you know you need formal advice, have a look at http://www.bankfield.net/ or ask around for a recommendation, it might even be me.